Bildungsroman?

freakysquirrelGlowing Halo
Bildungsroman?
Winner!
52,610 / 50,000
Official Participant
Joined: oct. 27, 2008
Location: Nebraska
Posts: 100
Posted on:
nov. 10, 2008 - 06 03

HI, should Bildungsroman novels be in literary or mainstream? My novel is somewhat like "Catcher in the Rye," updated, but it is set in 1973, as the Vietnam War is winding down.

----------

EmilyClaire

11,010 / 50,000
Official Participant
Joined: oct. 6, 2006
Location: Deepest, darkest Essex, UK
Posts: 36
Posted on:
nov. 10, 2008 - 07 11

Thanks for that. I've now found that my novel fits into a great historical novel form, which makes me quite happy.

BookHead
Winner!
53,988 / 50,000
Official Participant
Joined: oct. 16, 2008
Location: nomadic, but currently in Maryland, USA
Posts: 104
Posted on:
nov. 11, 2008 - 08 49

OH MY GOSH!!!! I think I jumped out of my chair when I saw someone reference to Bildungsroman! It is definatly Lit Fic. If you haven't already done so, read Huck Finn. If you have, do it again. I love Bildungsroman novels. Mine is a little, too, I suppose.

waxbanks
Winner!
50,270 / 50,000
Official Participant
Joined: oct. 14, 2005
Location: Cambridge, MA
Posts: 17
Posted on:
nov. 11, 2008 - 10 50

You're asking the wrong question. 'Mainstream' fiction is (in broad terms) just less complex storytelling with more plot (not to say 'more story,' mind you). Don't worry about where your story fits. The question is, 'Whom should I talk to about writing?' and the answer is, 'Everyone who has something to say - which is everyone.' You just have to know how to interpret the answers (i.e. any idiot can tell you that there's something wrong with your story, few can help you identify the flaw precisely, very few can tell you how to fix it - but it's OK to start with the idiot if you know how to parse his feedback).

'Literary' fiction isn't a terribly meaningful classification, except in commercial terms; broadly, it just means 'fiction that's about something other than the depicted events themselves.' See? Too broad to be too helpful.

Write what you're passionate about, read the forums for inspiration and fellowship if you must, but don't waste too much time here. Ultimately, when you're not writing, most of what you think about writing is bunk anyhow.

elephantguy

15,265 / 50,000
Official Participant
Joined: nov. 1, 2007
Location: Jersey
Posts: 15
Posted on:
nov. 11, 2008 - 11 38

waxbanks wrote:

'Literary' fiction isn't a terribly meaningful classification, except in commercial terms; broadly, it just means 'fiction that's about something other than the depicted events themselves.' See? Too broad to be too helpful.

Write what you're passionate about, read the forums for inspiration and fellowship if you must, but don't waste too much time here. Ultimately, when you're not writing, most of what you think about writing is bunk anyhow.

Well said Wax,

If you're worrying about what label to smack on it here in Nano land, you're missing the point. The key is to keep writing. I enjoy a nice bildungsroman from time to time, myself. But let's face it, the people who know what the term means aren't going to be impressed by your use of it, and those who don't know what it means probably aren't your audience. If they are, it's because you're writing a good story regardless of its classification.

Happily twisting ideas into a double helix of life-designing goo for my own purposes since the day I was born.

----------

Happily twisting ideas into a double helix of life-designing goo for my own purposes since the day I was born.

freakysquirrelGlowing Halo
Winner!
52,610 / 50,000
Official Participant
Joined: oct. 27, 2008
Location: Nebraska
Posts: 100
Posted on:
nov. 11, 2008 - 23 12

Okay, you're probably right, I should be over in mainstream. Too much plot, not enough meaning. Evidently I am not having any trouble writing it by my word count. And I used the term elephant, because it describes something, not because I wanted to impress someone. I don't call chairs cows either.

Didn't they tell Mozart he used too many notes?

radiondn

11,014 / 50,000
Official Participant
Joined: nov. 1, 2006
Location: American Midwest
Posts: 43
Posted on:
nov. 20, 2008 - 07 10

"Didn't they tell Mozart he used too many notes?"

That was just a movie.

Accueil :: A Propos :: Écrivains :: My NaNoWriMo :: FAQs :: Pour s'amuser :: Donation/Magasin :: Forums :: Programmes
Politique de confidentialité :: Privacy Policy :: Énoncé et conditions :: Politique de reprises :: Terms and Conditions :: Codes of Conduct :: Returns Policy

Copyright © 2008 The Office of Letters and Light :: All posted novel excerpts remain copyright their authors.
Powered by Drupal